2nd Amendment, Firearms

Causes of variation in firearm homicide and suicide rates across states.

Firearm homicide rate vs state giffords rank

tl;dr: Treating firearm deaths as a whole obscures fundamental differences in the way homicides and suicides vary across states. Variation in the firearm homicide rate is best explained by racial differences between the states, with gun laws having no explanatory power. The variation in the firearm suicide rate is best explained by a combination of differences in gun laws, gun ownership, and racial origin.

One often hears the argument that states with stricter gun laws have fewer firearm deaths. This is true, as the following plot of firearm death rates against the Gifford Law Center 1 ranking of states according to the strength of their gun laws shows2:

Firearm death rate
Firearm death rate (all causes) per 100,000 per year plotted against the 2016 Gifford Law Center ranking of each state’s gun laws. Source: Gifford Law Center and CDC.

R²=0.5264 roughly means that differences in gun laws (as measured by the Gifford rank) “explains” 52.64% of the variation in firearm death rates between states. So certainly the strength (or weakness) of firearm laws correlates significantly with firearm death rates, as one might expect.

However, correlation does not imply causation, so let’s dig deeper. What happens if we just consider firearm homicides (i.e. leave aside suicides and other causes of firearm deaths)?

Firearm homicide rate vs state giffords rank
Firearm death rate (homicides only) per 100,000 per year plotted against the 2016 Gifford Law Center ranking of each state’s gun laws. Source: Gifford Law Center and CDC.

The predictive power of gun laws disappears completely for firearm homicides: only 1.19% of the variation between states is explained by differences in gun laws, and in fact that variation is not significant (t-stat of 0.77 for the statistically inclined).

What about suicides?

Firearm suicide rate vs state giffords rank
Firearm death rate (suicides only) per 100,000 per year plotted against the 2016 Gifford Law Center ranking of each state’s gun laws. Source:Gifford Law Center and CDC.

Here we see the origin of the predictive power of gun laws: stronger laws are correlated with fewer firearm suicides, with 62.25% of the variation in firearm suicide rates across states explained by differences in their gun laws. Later we will look into the predictive power of ownership and gun laws together — it turns out they are highly correlated, as one might expect. But first, let’s dig deeper into the homicides.

Explaining the Firearm Homicide Rate

If gun laws don’t explain the variation in firearm homicide rates between the states, what could? To answer this, take a look at the following chart showing the firearm homicide rate for the US, broken down by racial origin of the victim:

Firearm homicide rate by racial origin of the victim
Firearm homicide rate by racial origin of the victim, all US states. Source: CDC.

There is a large disparity between the firearm homicide rates for victims of differing racial origin. Since there is also a large variation in the racial makeup of the states, a reasonable initial hypothesis is that the variation in firearm homicide victim rates between the states might be explained in part by the differences in racial makeup of the states.

To test this hypothesis we construct a predictor of the firearm homicide rate for a state by multiplying the state’s population percentage of each racial group by the corresponding US-wide firearm homicide rate for the racial group, and summing them up. Call this the Racial Origin Predictor (ROP) (the linked spreadsheet has the details).

It turns out that almost all (78.5%) of the variation in firearm homicide rates between states is explained by racial origin:

Firearm Homicide Rate vs Racial Origin Predictor
Firearm Homicide Rate vs Racial Origin Predictor across all states. Source: CDC.

Explaining the Firearm Suicide Rate

Firearm suicide rates also vary significantly by racial origin:

Firearm suicide rate by racial origin of the victim
Firearm suicide rate by racial origin of the victim, all US states. Source: CDC..

Given this variation, and the success of the Racial Origin Predictor (ROP) for firearm homicides, we might expect similar success for the ROP when predicting suicides. Surprisingly, this turns out not to be the case, with the ROP only accounting for 20.15% of the variation in firearm suicide rates between states, compared to 78.5% for firearm homicide rates.

Another candidate predictor is the firearm ownership rate, which turns out to be highly correlated to the Gifford Law Center rank (62.8%) and explains 54.06% of the variation in suicide rates between states.

The following chart shows the relative predictive power of various combinations of predictors (the chart shows adjusted R² which accounts for the fact that multiple predictors will always fit better than single predictors, even if the additional predictors have no explanatory power):

Firearm suicide rate predictor power
Firearm suicide rate predictor power for all combinations of ROP, Ownership, and Gifford State Rank predictors. Source:CDC, Injury Prevention, and Gifford Law Center.

Although the Gifford rank and ownership are significantly correlated, they do appear to provide complementary information, as the predictor set with the most explanatory power is the combination of ROP, ownership, and Gifford rank, with an adjusted R² of 75%. We’ll call this predictor ROPOG.

Residual Analysis

Now that we have separate predictors for firearm homicide (ROP) and suicide (ROPOG) rates that each explain upwards of 75% of the variation between states, we can look at the outliers in the residuals to try and understand why some states outperform or underperform with respect to the predictor. The following map shows the residual ROP score (i.e. the difference between the ROP prediction and the actual firearm homicide rate in the state):

state homicide residuals
Map of state residuals from the ROP predictor of firearm homicide rate.

New York, Virginia and Georgia are the three most extreme negative outliers, with firearm homicide rates 2.40, 1.92, and 2.06 lower than the value predicted by ROP. Consistent with the lack of explanatory power of the Gifford rank for firearm homicide rates, while New York has a relatively low rank (i.e stricter gun laws) of 5, Virginia’s rank is 21 and Georgia’s is 29. It would be useful to understand what these latter two states are doing right, for whatever it is, it does not appear to be a function of their gun laws.

At the other end of the spectrum we have Missouri and Louisiana with firearm homicide rates 2.64 and 2.26 above their predicted values respectively. In this case gun laws may be part of the cause, as they rank 48th and 43rd respectively on the Gifford scale, and Missouri also has relatively low ownership of 27.1%.

Turning now to the the residuals for the firearm suicide rate predictor (ROPOG):

state suicide residuals
Map of state residuals from the ROPOG predictor of firearm suicide rate.

On the extreme lower-than-expected side we have Massachusetts (-3.16) and Hawaii (-2.62). Massachusetts is interesting because it is already low on ownership (22.6%) and strict on guns (Gifford rank 4), yet still manages to have far fewer firearm suicides than predicted. As with Virginia and Georgia, it would be useful to understand what Massachusetts may be doing right. Hawaii is reasonably strict on guns (Gifford rank 7), but has a lot of them (ownership of 45.1%), so one could be tempted to conclude that it is simply a very pleasant place to live.

There appears to be a significant geographical component associated with outlier states in terms of excess firearm suicides: they are overrepresented in the mountain states and west of the Rockies: Nevada (+3.54), Oklahoma (+3.30), Oregon (+3.05), Colorado (+2.98), Montana (+2.69), New Mexico (+2.55), Wyoming (+2.28). The only outlier state in the east of a similar magnitude is Delaware (+2.75).

  1. District of Columbia is not ranked by the Gifford Law Center — it was added manually to the data with a rank of 3 which appears consistent with their criteria. The results are not sensitive to its inclusion. []
  2. The data and calculations used in this study are available here. []

55 thoughts on “Causes of variation in firearm homicide and suicide rates across states.

  1. It is actually a great and helpful pidce of information. I aam satiwfied
    that you shared this useful innformation with us.
    Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  2. We’re a bunch of volunteers and starting a new
    scheme in our community. Your web site provided us with helpful information to work on. You’ve
    performed a formidable activity and our entire community can be thankful to
    you.

  3. I just want to mention I’m all new to blogs and certainly savored you’re web site. More than likely I’m want to bookmark your site . You surely have good writings. Appreciate it for sharing your web page.

  4. Nice post. I was checking constantly this weblog and I’m impressed!
    Very helpful information specifically the last part :
    ) I care for such info much. I was seeking this certain info for a very lengthy time.

    Thanks and good luck.

  5. I think that everything published was very logical.
    However, consider this, suppose you added a little content?
    I ain’t saying your information is not good, however suppose you added a post title to possibly get
    folk’s attention? I mean Causes of variation in firearm
    homicide and suicide rates across states. – Dr.
    Jon B. is kinda plain. You ought to look at Yahoo’s front page and note how they create news titles to grab
    viewers to open the links. You might add a related video or a related picture or
    two to grab people interested about everything’ve written. Just my opinion, it might make your website a little livelier.

  6. Great goods from you, man. I have consider your stuff previous
    to and you are simply too magnificent. I actually like what you have
    received here, certainly like what you are stating and the
    way in which in which you assert it. You are making it enjoyable and you still take care
    of to keep it smart. I can not wait to learn far more from you.
    This is actually a great website.

  7. Hiya very nice website!! Guy .. Beautiful ..
    Wonderful .. I will bookmark your web site and take the
    feeds also? I am glad to seek out a lot of helpful information right here within the publish, we want develop more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing.
    . . . . .

  8. Thank you for the good writeup. It if truth be told
    used to be a entertainment account it. Look advanced to far added
    agreeable from you! However, how could we keep in touch?

  9. Ciekawy post, ogólnie się z Tobą zgadzam, jednak w niektórych kwestiach
    bym polemizowała. Z pewnością Twój blog może liczyć na uznanie.
    Z pewnością tu jeszcze wpadnę.

  10. I do not even understand how I ended up here, however I believed this put
    up was once great. I don’t recognise who you are however definitely you’re going to a
    well-known blogger in case you are not already.

    Cheers!

  11. What’s up friends, how is everything, and what you desire to say regarding this piece
    of writing, in my view its really amazing in support of me.

  12. Виртуальные забавы долгое время уж получили персональные честное область между энергичными юзерами сети интернета, также вовсе не упускают нас ежедневно тешить и поражать своими выпущенными деянием, победителями, результатами и мыслью от творцов. Происходит, что собственно для определенной гейм требуется окончательное установка плюс внедрение в данном индивидуальном ПК, но по современный день значительно удобней использовать выпущенные развлечение с помощью веб-платформы интернет- гейм, каковы общедоступные круглосуточно во время использовании интернета, также не вызывают лишнего периода к тому же места на телефоне собственно для установки. Если пользователь последователь всевозможных вымышленных гейм, тогда оптимальным местом досуга собственно для пользователей будет наш онлайн- ресурс браузерные шутеры, где уже соединенная подборка очень ходких также новых развлечений, в те что следует задействовать без фиксации.
    Веб сайт mmog-play.ru отработанный умышленно для истинных ценителей онлайн игр, также содержит к все это непохожие тематические, известные, топовые, юзерские, ресурсные, серийные также новые игры. Здесь на ресурсе достаточно рационально подобрать игровую выпуск на ваши индивидуальные вкусы, к тому же если же пользователь состоит сюда впервые, поскольку все игры правильно распределены по темам также род. В этом месте Вы имеют возможность найти надобную пробную игру:
    – на сеттингу : военные, исторические, мореплавающие, поразительные, мертвецы, пиратские также другие
    – благодаря геймплею : два Д, три Д, кооперативные, стратегия, погоня, самовыживание, разыгрыващие, тактические, MMOFPS, MMOTPS также иные
    – на свойствах: анимационные, зарубежные, русские, борьба, про роботов, вурдулаками, эльфов, волколаками, правдивые, магические, шуточные, протестированные и подобающие
    – соответсвенно рейтингу
    Удобный сервис в отбор интернет гейм показывает детальное определение игр, время выпуска, рейтинг плюс разряду, поэтому юзеры портала быстро имеют возможность устроить личные побуждение насчет тенденции – стратегичность, шутерские, экшн, ККИ, РПГ плюс подобные варианты, каковы точно принесут для Вас огромное количество свежих эффектов, мастерства и знакомств с иными юзерами. Заходите нашим сайт в сподручное время, сражайтесь в интернете, внедряйте и просматривайте всяческие обновление на презентованному ресурсу открытых интернет геймерских развлечений.

  13. Great – I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your website.
    I had no trouble navigating through all tabs and related information ended up
    being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least.
    Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, site theme .
    a tones way for your customer to communicate. Excellent task.

  14. I believe this is one of the most vital info for me.
    And i’m glad reading your article. But want to remark on some normal things, The website style is ideal, the articles is truly
    nice : D. Excellent process, cheers

  15. I am cսriоus to find out what blog platform you happen tto be uѕing?
    I’m eхpеdriencing some minor security problems with my latest ѡebsite and I would like to
    find something more ѕafe. Do you have any suggeѕtions?

  16. I d᧐ beliueve all оf the ideas you’ve introduced inn your
    post. They’re very convinncing and can certainly work. Nonetheⅼess, the posts
    are very quick for beginners. May you pⅼeasе lengthen them
    a bit from subsequent time? Thanks for the post.

  17. I was recommended this web site through my cousin. I’m not
    positive whether this post is written via him as nobody
    else understand such certain about my problem. You’re wonderful!

    Thanks!

  18. Greetings! Quick question that’s completely off topic.

    Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My website looks weird
    when viewing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to correct this problem.
    If you have any recommendations, please share. Many thanks!

  19. fantastic issues altogether, you just gained a new reader.
    What would you suggest about your publish that you simply made a few days in the past?
    Any positive?

  20. Hi there I am so thrilled I found your site, I really found you by error, while
    I was searching on Google for something else, Regardless I am
    here now and would just like to say thanks for a fantastic post and a all round enjoyable
    blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to go
    through it all at the minute but I have saved it and also included your RSS feeds, so
    when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the awesome jo.

  21. An outstanding share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a colleague who
    had been conducting a little homework on this.
    And he actually bought me lunch because I discovered it for him…
    lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thanks for the meal!!
    But yeah, thanx for spending time to talk about this matter here on your internet site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.